No alarm sounds as Neil Breen climbs out of bed at 4:30 a.m. He set his alarm for six, but his body clock woke him up earlier, as it has nearly every day for the last 11 months.
As soon as the sun comes up, he heads outside and laces up a pair of rollerblades for a three-mile fartlek sprint around a loop by his house in Florida (he’s since moved to Nebraska). Thatās followed by a hard 40-minute punching bag session and then weight training on alternating days.
Itās a drastic contrast from the first time The Chronicle spoke to Breen nearly two years ago. The former Quinnipiac menās hockey bruiser is almost 100 pounds lighter than he was then, and more significantly, has shed much of the crushing weight that years of brain-rattling head injuries had burdened him with.
Traumatic brain injuries, or āTBIs,ā are caused by repeated violent blows to the head, and are common in collision sports such as ice hockey. Such injuries have proven to serve as precursors to chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or āCTE,ā a progressive and fatal brain disease that can only be diagnosed after death.
ā(Itās) night and day,ā Neil said. āI was a mess, a big time mess. I would just lose track of what I was thinking and saying ā¦ I would say drastic improvement, and if you talk to any of my family members, they would say the same thing.ā
And they did.
āHeās done really well,ā Heather Breen, Neilās wife, said. āDo I think heās cured? No, I donāt really think there is a cure. But have I seen a huge difference? Absolutely.ā
After years of mounting symptoms that almost tore them apart, the Breen family: Neil, Heather and their two children, is stronger than ever, as evidenced by Heatherās latest tattoos, of bees.
āWeāre the killer bees,ā Heather said. āBecause our last name is Breen. Together weāre united, or whatever.ā
Neil has his own tattoos, all of which are equally meaningful, except for one of the Red Hot Chili Peppers logo, which Heather calls āhorrendous.ā She also wishes heād clean up around the kitchen more. But those shortcomings are nothing compared to what the pair dealt with before Neil embarked on his current healing path.
Angry outbursts were common for him. Drinking exacerbated the problem. The tension rose and rose, culminating in an ill-fated move from Connecticut to Florida.
āThereās four of us and our dog and heās pulling this huge 30,000-pound (trailer) and he was just screaming and freaking out,ā Heather said. āI thought it was going to be the end of us. Like not divorce, I thought we were just going to die.ā
But today there exists a much more mellow Neil. One who meditates when he wakes up in the morning and embraces conversations with his children about mental health.
āIāve made a lot of realizations and taken a lot of steps to improve my health,ā Neil said. āI was a miserable shell of my former self. And now I feel like Iām back, but thereās still a lot of unanswered questions.ā
The science of recovery
In his recovery, Neil took it upon himself to find the solutions that he had too long sought in medications.
āI was taking every medication under the sun to treat the symptoms that come along with CTE,ā Neil said. āDepression, anxiety, agoraphobia, all these things I was experiencing and I was just getting prescribed drug after drug and none of them worked.ā
Seeking alternatives to clear the fog and get his life back, he tried a one-time controlled use of the psychedelic drug ketamine.
āThere was other stuff like shrooms and Ayahuasca. Iām not doing that crazy shit,ā Neil said. āKetamine has at least been out on the market, it has a little bit more proven science behind it, so I went for it, and it worked.ā
Ketamine is a non-competitive N-methyl-D-aspartate glutamate receptor (NMDAR) antagonist, and considered a psychedelic under the broad definition of the term. Used medically as a form of anesthesia for decades, the FDA approved the use of ketamine as an antidepressant in 2019.
Research in recent years suggests that ketamine promotes neurogenesis, cell proliferation, synaptogenesis and an increase in white matter in the brain ā all of which aid in the regrowth of synaptic connections that have been severed as a result of unrelenting stress linked to depression and PTSD, according to John Krystal, professor of translational research, psychiatry, neuroscience and psychology at Yale.
Krystal co-authored a study in June 2023 that reported beneficial neural changes in patients suffering from PTSD following a single infusion of ketamine. He wrote in an Aug. 7 email to The Chronicle that the lack of research on the drug as a treatment with those suffering from conditions like Neilās make it difficult to conclusively determine its efficacy.
āIt is possible, but there has been very little study of ketamine effectiveness in TBI patients,ā Krystal wrote. āAn intriguing idea is that the neurotrophic (ānerve growthā) consequences of ketamine treatment might be helpful for TBI.ā
Neil used the telehealth service Mindbloom to administer the treatment at home. He recalls seeing a strong female warrior figure lead him through the experience.
āItās going to sound crazy, but some weird shit happened to me when I was tripping,ā Neil said. āI couldnāt really put it into words, but they just sort of showed me which way to walk and there were some symbols in there, stuff that I had to break down with a therapist afterwards.ā
Neil and his therapist concluded that the warrior represented the āwarrior lifestyleā he lived both as a hockey player and fighter, and that he could harness that to help others along the same path.
āI think the drug took me to places that Iād never been before subconsciously,ā Neil said. āAnd then the teaching and the work you do around it, like to learn how to meditate and stuff, just takes it even further.
āI learned how to control some of the behaviors I was experiencing and address setting intentions. Things youāve heard your whole life are good to do ā¦ those are actually things that became lifesavers for me.ā
Ā He began to simplify. Working out and training became a big part of his life again. Fasting made him feel strong and the switch to a carnivore keto diet heightened those feelings.
āI only eat animal products because I feel amazing,ā Neil said. āI feel like Iām 20 again.ā
But some question the sustainability of such a diet.
āHaving a diet that is that strict, there are potential repercussions,ā said Dana White, Quinnipiac sports dietitian and associate clinical professor of athletic training and sports medicine. āCarbohydrates are your primary source of energy. Your brain only runs on glucose ā¦ If no glucose is coming in, then it needs to be converted to something else and thatās not super efficient, just in terms of metabolism.ā
More than a one-sport issue
Neil may feel 20, but in reality, heās a 45-year-old who canāt be clinically diagnosed with CTE until after he dies. Itās one of the many things with the condition that makes it so hard to pinpoint.
āHeās done a lot better. Itās still hard. People donāt believe him, they think itās an excuse,ā Heather said. āIf youāre not diagnosed as it because you canāt be diagnosed as it until youāre gone, then they think itās just something youāre saying. And then as a spouse, youāre like both sides. Youāre supportive, but also like, āOkay, are they pushing it a little,ā and then you feel guilty that you would ever leave someone that would be in this situation.ā
The lasting impact of head injuries is not limited to former hockey players like Neil. Other athletes ā predominantly football players ā have gone through their own battles with CTE diagnosis. While heās a lucky one, former NFL defensive end and Super Bowl champion Zach Moore knows how dangerous these injuries can be.
āDocumented concussions, I definitely had several in college and in the league,ā Moore said. āIāve had a plethora of head injuries ā¦ Iāve read that if youāve played football for an extended period of time, thereās a 99% chance that youāll have CTE upon death.ā
It sounds crazy, but heās right. According to a 2017 Journal of the American Medical Association study, 99% of donated brains from former NFL players were diagnosed with CTE. The longer athletes played football, the worse the brain damage was.
Moore, whoās an International Sports Science Association certified personal trainer and licensed nutritionist, played five seasons in the NFL. Throughout his career ā including stops in six different cities ā he felt the collective weight that professional athletes feel, physically and mentally.
āBack when I was playing, it wasnāt really talked about,ā Moore said. āWeāre taught to be super aggressive, violent dudes ā¦ a lot of those spill into real life. It all correlates with our mental health.ā
Moore doesnāt know Neil. He didnāt know his story. Yet, as athletes in a physical game, the former NFL draft pick felt for the former hockey star.
āIt doesnāt matter how much money you make or what status your life is in, youāre not immune to what life can throw at you,ā Moore said. āDefinitely love yourself, take care of yourself and donāt be afraid to ask for help.ā
Thereās somewhat of a collective bond formed between athletes in high-contact sports. Itās what drew Breen to former USA Olympic bobsledder William Person, who he reached out to after reading an article in The New York Times about Personās lawsuit against USA Bobsled for its alleged nondisclosure of head injury risk in the sport.
āWilliam saved my life,ā Neil said. āIām going to the bank, and I couldnāt get out of the car to go in and Iād call William and be like, āDude, I canāt get out of the car, has this ever happened to you?ā And heād be like, āYeah, dude it happens all the time, itās this social anxiety thing.ā So Iām just sitting in there and heās talking me off the ledge just to get me to go into the bank and get some cash.ā
Neil has not fully overcome his symptoms, and likely never will. Both he and Heather acknowledge the incurable nature of traumatic brain injuries. But he has turned a corner in his recovery, and wants to help others do the same.
āI think itās important that people know that CTE or suspected CTE doesnāt have to be like this crazy, terminal thing,ā Neil said. āIf you do the right things, eat right, exercise, learn how to meditate ā¦ youāre going to have a great life, and you can put a lot of side effects to the wayside.
āI’m super stoked that I played the sport, and I always will be.”
Where hockey is concerned, Neil doesnāt want to tear down or radically change the sport. And he certainly doesnāt want people to think that he blames his alma mater for his ailments. His love for Quinnipiac remains strong. The national championship trophy is front and center in his LinkedIn Banner.
āI almost think I needed to cycle back and make sure that people knew I wasnāt trying to bring down the program or bring down hockey, I guess I was just looking for ways to get help,ā Neil said. āI even talked to (head coach) Rand (Pecknold), we had a good cry. Well I did, I donāt think he cried.
āSuper proud of him and what heās accomplished. Nothing Iāve said I hope ever hurts him. Heās a big influence and Iām happy the boys did it and Iām so proud to be a Bobcat.ā
But that doesnāt mean Neil doesnāt want the game to progress. He preaches smarter hitting strategies to his players.
āI tell guys, the best way to hit effectively is to separate the man from the puck, not to blow him up,ā Neil said. āIf you canāt make contact with a guy by putting stick on puck, hands on hands, body on body, if you canāt do that with control, you shouldnāt really be hitting. Youāre putting yourself at risk.ā
After spending much of his adult life as a coach in nearly every junior league in the U.S., there are aspects of the culture that irk him ā and the new Neil has no problem saying as much.
āThere are owners out there that donāt care, they just want you to sign the kid and take the money, and I just canāt do that,ā Neil said. āAnd when that happens, when Iām put in a position to make that choice or that decision, itās fight or flight. Itās like, āif you make me do that, Iām out of here.āā
That idea of putting the individual second is why Neil says āhockey guys donāt tell the truth,ā a sentiment amplified as the gameās biggest voices undermine the struggle of countless athletes like him by preaching a sermon of denial again and again in regard to the dangers of the sport.
ā(Neil) did his thing for the Lancers and Quinnipiac and all the other people.ā Heather said. āAnd now if you bring it up, itās like āHow dare you even say that CTE word around hockey that gave you this wonderful life,ā ā¦ Itās not right.ā
Dozens of former hockey players have been posthumously diagnosed with CTE, including NHL legends Stan Mikita, Henri Richard and Bob Probert. A 2022 Boston University preliminary study found that each additional year of playing the sport may increase the risk of CTE by 23%.
Hockeyās physical nature cannot simply be removed from the game. Itās too interwoven in its fabric. But what Neil and many others are seeking is for the sportās leaders to accept its consequences and adapt in response, promoting a smarter game and providing resources to prevent more lives from being derailed by the long-term impacts of head trauma.
The spiral that trauma sent Neil down pitted him against the game itself in his last interview with The Chronicle ā a mental war against the sport that shaped a lot of who he is, the good and the bad. Today, he sings a different tone, adamant in what hockey has done for him ā¦ for the most part.
āI think my mindset back then was if I never played hockey, I would have never been feeling this way,ā Neil said. āBut Iām in a place now where Iām super stoked that I played the sport, and I always will be. But there will always be times too where Iām like āDamn, why didnāt I choose basket weaving.āā
Breener • Sep 13, 2023 at 3:38 pm
Thanks fellas! Unreal work on this. Appreciate you all at QUC! Itās been a journey, much love!!!!
Brian • Sep 13, 2023 at 8:16 am
Super cool brother, but it was me that got u betterā¦.lol kidding bro. Glad you are doing much better.